Are employers allowed to discriminate in a job advert to hire a male teacher?

Written by: 

Are employers allowed to discriminate in a job advert to hire a male teacher?

Written by: 

If employers only hired employees from a certain background, particularly gender, work life would be monotonous, inefficient and needless to say pretty boring! Employers often make the mistake to discriminate against candidates when writing a job advertisement, whether or not that is done intentionally.

Legislation on this is blurry, especially as many employers and recruiters are not even aware of the fact they have written a discriminatory job advert. However, there are a few ways that employers can be more aware of this. After all, missing out on the perfect candidate just because the wording in a job advert is not inclusive would be a pity.

 

Nursery manager employing male early years educator | Male Childcare & Teaching Jobs

When can employers discriminate in a job advert to hire a male teacher?

Employers can specify that a candidate must have a protected characteristic if it is an occupational requirement or lawful positive action, which are both covered by an exception in the Equality Act 2010, Schedule 9.

According to Schedule 9 of the Equality Act 2010, positive action may be used to encourage candidates from under-represented groups to apply for your roles. Employers can in fact specify that the candidate must be from a particular group, in this case gender, if their nursery or school’s teaching workforce is predominantly made up of female staff.

 

Male Teacher walking out of a job interview | Male Childcare & Teaching Jobs

How can employers justify reasonable discrimination when advertising a job?

When advertising a job, employers need to make it clear why a certain ‘protected characteristic’ is required.

For example, a job description that might include a protected characteristic would be job advertising for a male teacher when the current teaching workforce is made up of women only. In this situation, most would understand why the protected characteristic is used.

It is crucial to consider the following when advertising a job:

  • Is there a valid reason why employers need to employ someone with a protected characteristic, in this case, a male teacher?
  • If an advertised job role doesn’t have a need for a protected characteristic, employers must make sure that their advert doesn’t mention/imply that any of the protected characteristics will be used when employing someone.
  • If a job role does require a protected characteristic to be successful, employers must be clear as to why it is required, and make mention of the law which is being used to allow the exemption.

 

Below are some examples of how employers can justify reasonable discrimination to hire male teachers:

  • Children need the presence of both female and male educators in their life to develop an awareness of gender equality.
  • The presence of both female and male educators prevents children from developing radicalised thoughts around genders, such as sexism. This helps promote British Values in nurseries and schools.
  • Children need the presence of friendly, non-violent male role models in their life, especially when they experience the lack of a father figure.
  • Children sometimes learn better from adults who are similar to themselves. Therefore, it’s crucial to have both genders educating children so that children of all genders can potentially feel comfortable learning.
  • Children need the presence of both female and male educators to minimise risks of developing unfair stereotyping around women and men later in life (e.g. women being more nurturing, whilst men being more hands-on with DIY work, to name a few)
  • Special Educational Needs remain more prevalent in boys than girls. Younger children with SEN might feel more comfortable with adults of their own gender, especially during certain routines like toileting. Therefore, it is essential to have male educators, as well as female, available to take care of SEN children.

 

Conclusion | Male Childcare & Teaching Jobs

Conclusion

In answering the original question “Are employers allowed to discriminate in a job advert to hire a male teacher?”, the answer is yes, they are in a few circumstances.

If employers have a role which they are unsure about, our best advice would be to speak to a legal professional specialising in employment law to make sure they don’t run afoul of discrimination laws.

For help employing male teachers and early years educators, we provide a wide range of services that will help employers diversify the gender of their team, from job posting, to marketing services and more!

To learn more about our all-inclusive membership, which provides nurseries and schools with the right tools to recruit staff, market their setting, support their male teachers and get ready for their Ofsted inspection, you can get in touch with our friendly team today.

Louise Mercieca | Nutritional Therapist and Early Years Nutrition Consultant

Louise Mercieca

Nutritional Therapist and Early Years NutritionConsultant

Bio:

At the intersection of health, nutrition, and early years education stands Louise Mercieca, a dynamic force in the realm of nutritional well-being for young children. A prolific writer with numerous articles and the notable book ‘How Food Shapes Your Child’ under her belt, she has delved deep into the intricacies of how food impacts a child’s development.

Her passion was kindled by two key elements: the journey she undertook with her young son and the extensive research she carried out for her debut book. Not just an author, Louise further extends her reach through the airwaves with her radio show ‘Food For Thought’ on Teacher Hug Radio.

Louise’s commitment doesn’t stop at raising awareness. As an Early Years Nutrition Consultant, she actively collaborates on menu development and nutritional education, ensuring that children receive a balanced and informed start to their dietary journey. Her driving belief is unequivocal: by understanding the bond between food and biology early on, we can preemptively address and potentially prevent many health and dietary issues adults grapple with later in life.

Her dedication to this cause positions her as a beacon for professionals in the Early Years sector, guiding them to understand the pivotal role food plays in holistic child health.

Sean Cowden | Chef Trainer at LEYF

Sean Cowden

Chef Trainer at LEYF

Bio:

In the vibrant world of child nutrition and culinary training, Sean Cowden shines as a beacon of expertise and dedication. As of 2022, he took the reins as Chef Trainer for LEYF’s esteemed Early Years Chef Academy courses. Initiated by LEYF in 2019, the Early Years Chef Academy emerged from a pressing need: to guarantee that young learners receive the essential, nutritious food vital for their growth and cognitive development. Through this initiative, chefs are meticulously trained not only in the culinary arts but also in the nuances of child nutrition, sculpting them into experts that inspire children, staff, and parents alike to cultivate lifelong healthy eating habits.

Before his esteemed tenure at LEYF Nurseries, Sean donned the hat of a Head Chef at an independent school, bringing his culinary flair to the academic arena. Additionally, his role as a Training Specialist for Gail’s Bakery further showcases his diverse expertise and unwavering commitment to the world of culinary arts and education.